What
is Tolkien's Mythology?
by Anthony S Burdge
Tolkien, at times, as compared to the Beowulf poet, felt
man’s one imaginative act is myth. (Helms,Tolkien's World,6)
That in poetic hands, it becomes a largely significant,
profound human endeavor. “A learned man writing of old times,”
Tolkien felt the poet in his sub-creation (a secondary world
to our own) should deal, as myth does, with deep moral and
spiritual issues. (Helms,Tolkien's World,6) One should
not have to wholly ascribe to the verbal skill or metre
of the form either.
In
reviewing the forgotten literary form of the Northern eddies,
Tolkien wished to provide his people with an epic of their
own. In so providing this epic, Tolkien wished to put us
back in touch with nature in an age overrun by machines.
In
awe of our living universe, Tolkien sought to provide man
with the same primordial contact that he saw in the eddies.
The imagined wonder of an archaic mode of life, within the
realm of forests and fairy-storied, was part of what Tolkien
provides. Inherently tied to myth, and fairy-stories, was
its allegorical language, of which, direct conscious allegory
he disliked.
"There
is no ‘allegory,’ moral political or contemporary in the
work at all… It is a fairy-story." The relevance of the
tale must have some elements of the “human situation,” “to
exemplify general principles,” and “to deliver us from ‘evil.’”
One of the beauties of the Beowulf poem was the embodiment
of evil in the monsters. In The Lord of the Rings the evil
of Sauron is embodied in the ring. On the other side are
these “vulgar and simple goodly hobbits” whom he loved,
would move from the simple to the noble in this act. He
felt he did not invent the tale, he was meant to do it,
capturing what lay on the edge of consciousness.
In
so providing this secondary world, Tolkien has not embodied
one god, though a monotheistic tale. The Creator, Eru of
the Silmarillion, is only directly accessible through the
Rulers as the Valar. Tolkien admits “a… mythological structure
to the story… a monotheistic but sub-creational mythology.”
Though, the one god does retain all ultimate authority.
This
sub-creation of Tolkien’s began with language and through
language these “myths” or “legends” began to take shape.
These “myths” had to be believable and in accordance with
the laws of our world. “We make still by the law in which
we’re made.” (Helms,Tolkien's World, 13)
A
prime example for the basis of his languages that lead to
the myth is Finnish, and the language of the Kalevala. He
felt its form was hapless and wished to reorganize it into
a form of his own. The phonetic pattern and structure of
the elvish languages Tolkien admits is heavily Finnacized.
The
world of Arda, or Middle-earth, in his tales, especially
that of The Lord of the Rings, is his sub-creation. It is
world in touch with its primordial essence and in accordance
with the laws of our own. The evils Middle-earth relate,
as Tolkien admits to the exploration of radical evil. Its
basis is the Judeo-Christian form of Satan. With an outside
power, a malevolent force parallels Tolkien’s Christianity.
Against this evil man is doomed, but this is where Tolkien’s
other influences come into play. Being learned in the Norse,
Germanic, Tolkien ennobles the most humble and strengthens
the weak. It is through these archetypal mythological representations
that Tolkien helps us perceive our own reality.